| Wednesday, December 27, 2006 |
| When it reviews--er--rains, it pours. |
A blogger with a dislike for pop and punk reviews O!G. here.
Cheryl thinks this album will take Switchfoot to Laguna Beach.
A lesser Jon thinks that Switchfoot's multi-platinum success gave Jon Foreman "severe second thoughts" about his faith. A bold accusation. Slow to understand and quick to judge?
Soul Shine Magazine heaps 4 stars on the album.
A well-written review on the "great" album, from sputnikmusic.
The Relevant Magazine review, which opens with a terribly misinformed line, seems to care more about the cool than about the music (Thanks Luke for transcribing!):
No one ever takes Switchfoot seriously. And no wonder: Their latest release is just further proof that enthusiastic yowls and yelps from a blonde-haired Californian can sell records faster than any label head ever dream. Yet even their hit songs have an underlying intelligence and (watch out secular radio) spiritual fervor. The themes are always about making the most of your time on earth, crawling before you walk (or just being content with crawling).
Of course, there is still a lot of yelping. Frontman Foreman just can't help himself on songs like "Burn Out Bright," which seems like an imitation of former glories. And while the promising "Dirty Second Hands" single hinted at an early-period Rolling Stones revival musically, these are all mostly alterna-anthems for suburbia. "Awakening" is the best toe tapper here, escalating into a palatable Nirvana state, but its still just a bunch of crazy guitars and scorching vocals from a cool white dude.
Yet, Switchfoot is an interesting anomaly. The band members write literary exurban odes that wink wink at you about fleeting stardom. They know, for example, that driving a Lexus has a certain appeal (on "American Dream") and sure, the camera is pointed in their direction, and its owned and operated by MTV. But every great gift on this earth pales in comparison to eternal bliss. They're saying, go ahead and smell the roses, but remember who made them and don't get too distracted. Oh! Gravity. gets better with each listen because you start to hear truth among the posing.
The only gripe with the band is that they keep hinting at the answer, and even sort of call you over to the cross and say "God's right over here," but never really play their hand. They're the best band in Christian music who could be atheists, and often pass too easily for Foo Fighters light. It might be easy for some people to choose any door (Scientology? Buddhism?) on the road out of the city of negativity. -John Brandon Is that even a real review? I mean, talk about the music yo. And I guess, if you become successful and you sing about the lures of success, you're a poser? Hmm. Or did I miss something?Labels: album reviews. |

posted by phil @ 2:55 AM  
 |
|
| 4 Comments: |
-
you would think of all reviewers, that Relevant, the liberal Xian magazine for youth, would've "gotten it."
-
bee tee double-yoo, cousin.
everytime i go to wahoo's i grab a bunch of switchfoot stickers, jsut cause...they're switchfoot stickers. so seeing how i can only put stickers on so many cars/closets/trunks/desks, i have a handful to give away. if you plan on throwing a contest, etc. i can mail them to you.
hope your holidays were good. btw, check out the band "paper route" at www.paperrouteonline.com freakin amazing stuff.
-
Relevant mag.. are you kidding me? I'll have to agree with what Tina said.
-
"They're the best band in Christian music who could be atheists."
Dear Relevant mag,
Please make sure your reporters aren't using any of the following before, during or after writing an album review:
Meth Weed Cocaine Ecstacy Acid Heroin Marijuana
I think one slipped by you. Thanks.
|
| |
| << Home |
| |
|
|
|
you would think of all reviewers,
that Relevant, the liberal Xian magazine for youth, would've "gotten it."